Early Black FridayFree shipping · 50% off your second book50% off 2nd book · free shipping
The booksBuying guidesBy occasionCompare brands

Compare personalized books

TinyShelf vs
Magic Story.

TinyShelf and Magic Story both turn a child's photo into an illustrated character. Compare the amount of personalized preview, the story and cast, and what you can check before the hardcover is printed.

Published by TinyShelf · Sources checked November 7, 2026

See the differences

Scroll sideways to compare both companies.

Compare the experience, then check the exact book you want.
What mattersTinyShelfFeatured storybooksMagic StoryDetails from linked sources
How the child appearsA character illustrated from your child's photo, with their name in the story and artwork.A photo becomes the child's illustrated likeness and outfit throughout the story. [1]
Before buyingFor the featured book, preview your cover and first three spreads free before payment.A free personalized scene or cover, rather than every page. No account or card is needed for that preview. [1]
More than one personChoose a listed book for a child and dog, two children, or a child and grandparent. Each book has its own cast.Some companion titles include a parent, grandparent, sibling, friend or pet. Choices vary by book. [1]
Words and picturesAI illustrations personalize the chosen story. After payment, request word or picture changes and approve before print.Uses AI for photo-based characters. Magic Story+ offers a monthly personalized hardcover and app reading. [1]
Printed formatThe featured storybooks are 32-page, 8.5 × 8.5 inch hardcovers. A digital edition is included.Its comparison guide describes a landscape hardcover. Check the chosen title for its page count. [2]

When TinyShelf fits

You want to check the likeness and shape the finished book.

Choose a photo-based character, a story with the right cast, and the option to request word or picture changes after payment. Read and approve the finished pages before we print.

See the photos, pages and editing →

When Magic Story fits

Choose the experience you prefer.

Consider Magic Story if you prefer its landscape books, story catalog, music features or monthly hardcover plan. A one-time book purchase is also offered. Read the chosen title's preview and plan details before buying.

Visit Magic Story →

Read the actual sample

Open the first three spreads.

Read the words and inspect the characters before choosing a story. The spreads below are actual sample page exports. Where a text reading is included, it transcribes the words in that sample. Photo-to-character panels use styled product images made from the sample artwork.

One child and their own dog

The Runaway Sheep

Sample: Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep

Ages 3 to 8

The sample photos and illustrated characters in Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep
From the sample photos to the painted characters. Eli and Biscuit appear in this title’s own personalization proof. Styled product image made from the sample artwork.
Opening spread 1Actual sample page export · Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep

The farm gate swings open on Fair Day, and Eli and Biscuit watch the whole flock run into town.

Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 1

Words from opening spread 1

It was Fair Day, and every sheep on Hilltop Farm was going to the fair. Then the gate swung open. Out came the whole flock, down the hill and straight into town. On the farm lane, Eli and Biscuit stopped the wagon and stared.

Read spread 1 at full size
Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 1

Swipe or scroll across the spread to read the type. Open the full-resolution image in a new tab ↗

Opening spread 2Actual sample page export · Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep

Eli’s name is painted on the wagon as they watch the sheep head the wrong way.

Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 2

Words from opening spread 2

The wagon had Eli painted on the side in big red letters, all ready for the fair. Eli knelt down beside Biscuit, and together they watched the sheep go by. So many sheep. And not one of them was going the right way.

Read spread 2 at full size
Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 2

Swipe or scroll across the spread to read the type. Open the full-resolution image in a new tab ↗

Opening spread 3Actual sample page export · Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep

Sheep are scattered across town, but every one needs to reach the fair’s empty pen by noon.

Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 3

Words from opening spread 3

From the top of the hill, Eli and Biscuit could see sheep everywhere: on the bridge, on the library steps, and one in a flower box. Down at the fair, the sheep pen stood empty. The fair opened at noon, and every sheep had to be in that pen.

Read spread 3 at full size
Eli & Biscuit and the Runaway Sheep, opening spread 3

Swipe or scroll across the spread to read the type. Open the full-resolution image in a new tab ↗

Preview the cover and first three spreads free. After checkout, review the finished book before print approval.

For these storybooks, word or picture changes can be requested after checkout and before approving print. Use your own finished pages to check the likeness.

See The Runaway Sheep →

From TinyShelf customers

What made the book feel personal.

“Gorgeous books. Adding the personalization and photos couldn't be easier, and the finished piece is delightful. I'm three purchases in and there will be more.”
TinyShelf customer
“I love the standard of the artwork and how the personalization carries through the story's whole message, not just the cover.”
TinyShelf customer
“Great book — loved the customization and the personal dedicated page.”
TinyShelf customer

Selected comments about our personalized storybooks. These are shared TinyShelf customer experiences; they are not reviews of every title shown here. Delivery experiences vary.

Looking for Magic Story alternatives?

Start with the feature that matters to your family: a photo-based character, another cast, a different story or a different preview. Our guide to choosing personalized books for kids compares TinyShelf, Wonderbly, Hooray Heroes, Magic Story, I See Me! and Librio, with specific publisher sources.

Meet the books

A story for your kind of family.

Compare the delivered total.

TinyShelf prices above come from the current catalog for your selected market. Other companies' prices depend on the title, binding, offers and shipping address. Compare hardcover with hardcover, include delivery and tax, and check whether a price is a one-time purchase or a subscription.

Sources and scope

This is TinyShelf's own comparison, not an independent ranking or a print-quality test. Competitor details describe the linked products and pages as checked on November 7, 2026; their catalogs and offers can change. An option not described here may exist on another title.

  1. Magic Story: The Night I Saved Christmas, preview, characters and subscription
  2. Magic Story: its own guide to personalization and formats

For TinyShelf details, see the linked product pages, refund and print policy, and privacy policy.